March 21, 2005

Terri Schiavo Update

First, a quick update: a Federal Judge will rule at 3:00 PM today whether to reinsert Terri Schiavo's feeding tube. Let's pray that he does.

Another question that you may be able to help with: Why should a spouse ever be able to starve the other spouse to death? I understand the argument where a patient can be taken off of life support (brain dead, etc). But this isn't that type of case. Mr. Schiavo has been given permission by judges to starve his wife to death because she has been disable. To make matters worse, her parents are simply asking that he turn her over to them and not worry about it. But no, Mr. Schiavo is determined to kill his wife - I just don't understand why that is ever legal.

Any person would die without food or water (and it's a horrible way to die), so where did Terri Schiavo lose her Constitutional right to life. And what does this say about those disabled people who need help on a daily basis. In other words, if we can simply kill another by starving them to death, where do we draw the line? What if Terri Schiavo could swallow and thus only needed someone to help feed her by mouth, rather than a tube. Would she still deserve to die? This is terribly slippery slope.

And for the record, I think it's important to note what the newscasters are glossing over:


  • 1st Michael Schiavo sued and won over a million dollars so that he could give her the rehabilitation she needed. In the case, doctors testified that this would help her.
  • Next, Michael Schiavo decided (after getting this money) that she really didn't need the rehabilitation, so she has never gotten it (just a tiny bit at first from my understanding of the case).
  • Then a few years later, Michael Schiavo meets his current live in "fiance" with whom he has two children
  • Seven years after the accident that left Terri disabled (and after he had proposed to his new fiance), Michael Schiavo and his brother remember conveniently that Terri wanted to die if left in this condition. There is no other evidence other than the oral testimony of these two and Michael's sister-in-law that Terri wanted to be starved to death.
  • Michael begins a long court process to kill his wife. When he begins there is a significant amount of money left from the settlement that will become Michael's only if Terri dies. I have seen nothing that explains how much of that money is left, but I'm betting little.
  • Terri's parents - the Schindler's - repeatedly ask that Michael simply turn Terri over to them for care and go on with his new life. He refuses and they are the ones fighting for Terri's life.

Last night someone made the comment that according to Florida law, a contract for over $500 was only valid if in writing, but this husband can starve his wife to death on nothing but hearsay. And Governor Bush also pointed out that if Terri had committed a terrible crime he could pardon her, but the courts won't allow him to save an innocent woman.

Personally, it's very sad to me that our culture had declined to this point. Much prayer is needed.

God bless,
Jay

Posted by Jay at March 21, 2005 01:55 PM | TrackBack

Comments

While I find it plausible that Terry may wish to die in her current state, I cannot imagine anyone in their right mind wanting to starve to death. I also have trouble imagining people cruel enough to choose starvation as the means to end Terry's life - but America has millions.

While I deplore the decision to end the life of Terry Schiavo, a lethal injection would seem a more humane way to go about this. Hardened criminals who have lost their constitutional right to life receive this mercy. What need do we have of adding the sins of cruelty and torture to the crime of murder?

Miserere Nobis

Posted by: Broken Record at March 22, 2005 03:03 PM

Broken Record,

Paradoxically, the problem is that while they can withhold action to sustain life, they cannot legally act in such a way that would prematurely extinguish that life. In the law's eyes that would indeed be murder. This whole situation and the resulting litigation leads to this very bitter irony, even the worse mass murderers get better treatment than Terri is receiving . . .

In Christ,


Thomas

Posted by: Thomas at March 22, 2005 04:56 PM

Post a comment











Remember personal info?






 
The Bloggers
Danny Young married Catholic
Jay Baptist convert
Joe Cradle Catholic

Categories
Recent Comments
On Prayer Requests
elaine
said:
Father, I bring before Your throne all those who are in need of a share of Your healing and peace, E... [read more]


On Becoming Catholic: Francis Beckwith’s reasons
Randy
said:
Those early church fathers, it is amazing how powerful they are in completely destroying the protest... [read more]


On Islam: A lesson for Christianity
Burnt Marshwiggle
said:
It almost seems like we have a historical "paper-scissor-rock" situation where people choose weak-Ch... [read more]


On A strong presidential candidate for Christians
Daniel
said:
I was thinking of "power" in the secular sense of the word - economic, political, military, etc. Bu... [read more]


On The Patron Saint of the Americas
Burnt Marshwiggle
said:
Michael O wrote: That being said, I feel more of a devotion to Our Lady each passing day. I appr... [read more]


On Who is the Woman Clothed in the Sun of Revelation 12?
samantha
said:
this woman isat war with bablylondon the great, or vice versa . she is a natural country type who li... [read more]


On Why can’t non-Catholics receive Holy Communion?
Burnt Marshwiggle
said:
Sandra, If you need help with the sacrament of confession, I would highly recommend reading a book ... [read more]


On What’s the point of Godparents? The Role of the Godmother and Godfather
Burnt Marshwiggle
said:
Mary, Yes, this has been possible since the Second Vatican Council (I can find the reference from t... [read more]


On Contact Information
Ken Kelley
said:
Please help me in finding someone or forwarding this to someone who has the gift of the Holyghost in... [read more]


On Clean Shopping, Clean Conscience
when we were one
said:
Lacey St. Thomas Aquinas noted that God created only good... what man chooses to do with his creati... [read more]


Communities
Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.