Even though I greatly appreciate most of the work Dr. Dobson has done over the years, I think his books on parenting especially those dealing with boys and teenagers should be avoided because he condones masturbation. As a former sex education teacher, who even used the Focus on the Family video regarding safe sex as being a lie for those engaging in premarital sex, I think his attitude on masturbation is troubling and to say the least gravely immoral. Below is an article I found posted on his website dealing with the issue.
Question:
My thirteen-year-old son is in the full bloom of adolescence. I'm suspicious that he may be masturbating when he's alone, but I don't quite know how to approach him about it. Should I be concerned, and if so, what should I say to him?
Dr. Dobson Responds:
I don't think you should invade that private world at all unless there are unique circumstances that lead you to do so. I offer that advice while acknowledging that masturbation is a highly controversial subject and Christian leaders differ widely in their perspectives on it. I will answer your question but hope you understand that some Bible scholars will disagree emphatically with what I will say.
First, let's consider masturbation from a medical perspective. We can say without fear of contradiction that there is no scientific evidence to indicate that this act is harmful to the body. Despite terrifying warnings given to young people historically, it does not cause blindness, weakness, mental retardation, or any other physical problem. If it did, the entire male population and about half of females would be blind, weak, simpleminded, and sick. Between 95 and 98 percent of all boys engage in this practice — and the rest have been known to lie. It is as close to being a universal behavior as is likely to occur. A lesser but still significant percentage of girls also engage in what was once called "self-gratification."
As for the emotional consequences of masturbation, only four circumstances should give us cause for concern. The first is when it is associated with oppressive guilt from which the individual can't escape. That guilt has the potential to do considerable psychological and spiritual damage. Boys and girls who labor under divine condemnation can gradually become convinced that even God couldn't love them. They promise a thousand times with great sincerity never again to commit this despicable act. Then a week or two passes, or perhaps several months. Eventually, the hormonal pressure accumulates until nearly every waking moment reverberates with sexual desire. Finally, in a moment (and I do mean a moment) of weakness, it happens again. What then, dear friend? Tell me what a young person says to God after he or she has just broken the one thousand first solemn promise to Him? I am convinced that some teenagers have thrown over their faith because of their inability to please God at this point of masturbation.
The second circumstance in which masturbation might have harmful implications is when it becomes extremely obsessive. That is more likely to occur when it has been understood by the individual to be "forbidden fruit." I believe the best way to prevent that kind of obsessive response is for adults not to emphasize or condemn it. Regardless of what you do, you will not stop the practice of masturbation in your teenagers. That is a certainty. You'll just drive it underground — or under covers. Nothing works as a "cure." Cold showers, lots of exercise, many activities, and awesome threats are ineffective. Attempting to suppress this act is one campaign that is destined to fail--so why wage it?
The third situation around which we should be concerned is when the young person becomes addicted to pornographic material. The kind of obscenity available to teenagers today has the capacity to grab and hold a boy for the rest of his life. Parents will want to intervene if there is evidence that their son or daughter is heading down that well-worn path.
The fourth concern about masturbation refers not to adolescents but to us as adults. This habit has the capacity to follow us into marriage and become a substitution for healthy sexual relations between a husband and wife. This, I believe, is what the apostle Paul meant when he instructed us not to "deprive" one another as marital partners: "Do not deprive each other except by mutual consent and for a time, so that you may devote yourselves to prayer. Then come together again so that Satan will not tempt you because of your lack of self-control" (1 Corinthians 7:5).
As for the spiritual implications of masturbation, I will have to defer to the theologians for a more definitive response. It is interesting to me, however, that Scripture does not address this subject except for a single reference in the Old Testament to a man named Onan. He interrupted sexual intercourse with his sister-in-law and allowed his semen to fall on the ground to keep from producing offspring for his brother, which was his "duty" (Genesis 38:8). Though that verse is often cited as evidence of God's disapproval of masturbation, the context doesn't seem to fit.
So, what should parents say to their kids about this subject? My advice is to say nothing after puberty has occurred. You will only cause embarrassment and discomfort. For those who are younger, it would be wise to include the subject of masturbation in the "Preparing for Adolescence" conversation I have recommended on other occasions. I would suggest that parents talk to their twelve- or thirteen-year-old boys, especially, in the same general way my mother and father discussed this subject with me. We were riding in the car, and my dad said, "Jim, when I was a boy, I worried so much about masturbation. It really became a scary thing for me because I thought God was condemning me for what I couldn't help. So I'm telling you now that I hope you don't feel the need to engage in this act when you reach the teen years, but if you do, you shouldn't be too concerned about it. I don't believe it has much to do with your relationship with God."
What a kind thing my father did for me that night in the car. He was a very conservative minister who never compromised his standards of morality to the day of his death. He stood like a rock for biblical principles and commandments. Yet he cared enough about me to lift from my shoulders the burden of guilt that nearly destroyed some of my friends in the church. This kind of "reasonable" faith taught to me by my parents is one of the primary reasons I never felt it necessary to rebel against parental authority or defy God. Well, those are my views, for what they are worth. I know my recommendations will be inflammatory to some people. If you are one of them, please forgive me. I can only offer the best advice of which I'm capable. I pray that in this instance, I am right.
His response has several problems.
1. He begins his response by stating that masturbation is a highly controversial issue with several different biblical scholars but fails to list their names and positions. He admits and rightly so that many will emphatically disagree with him on this subject. I think this is a good example how the doctrine of Sola Scripture causes division and leads to moral relativism, because according to Dobson the Bible doesn't mention masturbation specifically and therefore he has the right to believe masturbation to be alright, an action having little to do with your relationship with God. The Catholic Church has always taught that masturbation is an intrinsically and gravely disordered action. CC pg.564 #2352 Masturbation, when done with full knowledge and consent of the will, is a sin. Now, please explain to me how a sin doesn't affect one's relationship with God.
2. He argues his case from a medical perspective stating a statistic with no reference as to who performed this survey and how it was conducted. His statistics prove that every man has masturbated. Jesus was a man, does this mean Jesus masturbated? Then he states that a significant number of girls engage in what was once called "self-gratification". I didn't realize this view had changed.
3. He then goes on to state that there are only four circumstances which cause only emotional consequences which parents should be concerned with. Notice he doesn't believe there are any moral or spiritual consequences when one practices masturbation. His first circumstance is oppressive guilt. Basically, his line of thinking here is that every teen is going to masturbate and their guilt can lead them into losing their relationship with God so don't make them feel guilty for their actions. Just because masturbation might be a universal problem doesn't dismiss the fact that it is wrong. I think universally man deals with the same types of several different sins - selfishness, pride, lust, lying, etc. and we feel guilt for these actions. Guilt should be felt and should lead us back to Christ no matter how many times we fail even if it is a 1,000 times if we ask, Christ said he would forgive us over and over again. There is no end to his mercy, love, and forgiveness.
4. His next circumstance is when masturbation becomes extremely obsessive. Again he offers a parent no guide to determine when masturbation reaches this point and in fact states they are going to do it anyway so why wage a war against it, there is no cure. What about prayer? Do you mean Christ can not give one the grace to conquer this sin? Apparently not, according to Dobson there is no cure so don't condemn the action to your teens. I find this attitude extremely disturbing because this is same attitude I was fed as a teenager regarding premarital sex. Everybody is going to do it so why wait? Teenagers have no control over their hormones so hand them condoms, they're going to have sex anyway. I know Dobson doesn't feel this way about premarital sex which baffles me why he views masturbation to be different.
5. His third circumstance for concern is when masturbation leads to pornography addiction. Again his advice is weak for parents. The crazy advice I find is that when masturbation leads to this action then it is O.K. for parents to condemn the action and to intervene. Wouldn't it be wiser to intervene before this becomes an issue? If I had a child who struggled with a weight problem, would I wait until he/she is 300 lbs. overweight to deal with the issue or would I teach them from a young age about proper nutrition and exercise? The same should be applied with our sexuality. If I know most or all male teens (according to Dobson) are going to masturbate, would I not teach my child from toddlerhood on about sexual morality? Would I not show them God's design for our bodies in regards to marriage and the sexual act and how other actions distort this act and hurt our relationship with God and others? Why would I wait until the issue was out of control as he suggests?
6. His fourth circumstance I find to be ironic considering his other advice, because would it not follow that if you condone masturbation to your teens, as he suggests, that this behavior would become habit as an adult and interfere with your marital relationship? In fact, masturbation began affecting your marital relationship from the moment you started practicing it, because it distorts God's design for sex. God designed sex to be an act of mutual self-giving, ever unitive and open to procreation. Masturbation distorts this act by being self indulgent and completely closed to life.
7. He then gives reference to spiritual implications by referring to the story of Onan in the OT (Genesis 38:8) however, he dismisses this reference as not applicable to the context of masturbation. However, he is wrong. The sin Onan committed was wasting "his seed", ejaculating outside of a woman essentially. What is masturbation for a male, but ejaculating outside of a woman and wasting "one's seed". It is considered wasting one's seed because semen is a life-giving substance with the ability of creating new life within a woman. Thus God created the sexual act to be open to life at all times. Hence, when Onan freely chose to indulge in sexual pleasure yet refused to be open to life, God disapproved. In fact if you read the story of Onan God disapproved so much that He killed Onan. So according to the Bible wasting "one's seed" is a serious offense against God with eternal ramifications. Something not to be dismissed, is it no wonder people deal with such guilt over the act of masturbation? Perhaps masturbation was never directly mentioned in the Bible because not that many people struggled with it at the time due to the fact that many married while in their teens unlike today.
In conclusion, I strongly disagree with Dobson as does the Church and believe parents should read his material with caution. Masturbation is a sin and wounds one relationship with Christ however, there is a cure and his name is Jesus. He can help you overcome any sin.
An excellent book on this subject is My Beautiful Feeling by Walter and Ingrid Trobisch.
Peace in Christ,
Maria